Build the number in four parts

Suppliers quote machine prices. Buyers need cost per pack. The two are not the same, and the gap is where most purchasing decisions go wrong.

Build the number in four parts.

1. Labour per pack. Take the hourly cost of the person packing, including the costs that sit on top of wages, and divide by the packs that person produces in an hour. If one person wraps 300 packs an hour and costs X per hour, labour is X divided by 300. Do this for your own numbers; the result varies enormously between markets.

2. Film per pack. Weigh a full roll and a used roll, or count packs between roll changes. Then divide the film cost by the packs it covered. This is where a wider film or a looser tension quietly costs money.

Payback, and what suppliers leave out

3. Stops and rework. Count packs that have to be rewrapped in a shift. Each one costs labour twice and film twice. A machine that produces a consistent pack usually wins here, even when its rated speed is lower.

4. Consumable changes. How often does the film roll change? Every change is a stop. A machine that runs an hour between changes and one that runs thirty minutes have different real output, whatever the catalogue says.

Now compare. Cost per pack on a machine is labour divided by packs, plus film per pack, plus an allowance for maintenance and spares. Cost per pack by hand is labour divided by packs, plus film, plus rework.

Payback is the machine price divided by the saving per pack, divided again by packs per year. If the answer is under two years, the decision is usually easy. If it is over four, look again at whether you are sizing for peak demand you rarely reach.

When manual packing still wins

Two things suppliers leave out of these comparisons, and you should not. First, space and workflow: a machine that blocks the counter can cost more in staff time than it saves. Second, training: a machine that one person can learn in an afternoon is worth more than one that needs a specialist.

Run the calculation with your own labour rate, your own film use and your own rework count. If the numbers are close, the deciding factor is usually consistency rather than speed.

Send us your packs per shift, your labour rate and your film use, and we will work through the comparison with you, including the cases where manual packing is still the right answer.